Generation Gap Carousel

Generation Gap Carousel

Happy New Year! I trust that by now many of you have checked out our January profile of Mikel Rouse and, if not, will do it now! These profiles are always a lot of fun to make, and this one generated plenty of insights for me, as I find myself straddling a fence between one musical generation and another, able to catch a glimpse of each one from the in-limbo state of a person almost exactly between the two—ten years younger than those who were artistically very active during the 1980s, and ten years older than those finding their creative voices in the beginning of the 21st century.

As Mikel spoke about his early experiences with the band Tirez Tirez, the ensemble Broken Consort, and about the challenges he has faced—and still does—in finding a home (i.e. genre) for his music, it sounded just like the struggles many composers face now who are writing music that doesn’t automatically fit into a prescribed genre. Thirty years ago Rouse and others were already making what has now become known as “Indie-classical” or, um, “this alt-classical stuff.” While it is clear that “bandsembles” are not new inventions, the current incarnations are happening with original twists, just as earlier groups presented angles and approaches of their own. For instance, composer-driven ensembles have often in the past (as one would expect) been focused on the work of that single composer. The Philip Glass Ensemble plays the music of Philip Glass, Steve Reich and Musicians plays the music of Steve Reich, and Mother Mallard’s Portable Masterpiece Company for the most part played the music of David Borden. Among groups formed within the past five to ten years, the emphasis on community building and the means by which music is disseminated provide a different slant. In 2011 numerous ensembles have composer members and/or function as composer/performer collectives, such as NOW Ensemble, Newspeak, Dither Quartet, Ne(x)tworks, Imani Winds, ICE, etc. While they do, of course, perform the music of those composer-members, they also play music by many, many other composers. And in addition to fostering a real sense of community, respect, and friendship between composers and performers, they are making significant headway into changing the way contemporary music is presented by throwing genre specifications to the wind and opening up into the spaces where different styles of music meet. As much as I think this is fabulous for us all, there is so much fussing and fuming about this topic! Change can be hard, folks, but look at it this way; it’s not new, it’s just different.

Just as one can hear plenty of “older” composers grumbling about current events in the new music scene, “Who do these kids think they are?? They didn’t invent this music! We’ve been doing this for decades!” at the same time the “youngsters” are pooh-pooh-ing “Those crusty people over 30! Totally clueless!” Far more interesting to me is witnessing some heartwarming bridges between the generations, in the forms of, to name just a few, Molissa Fenley choreographing to the music of Lainie Fefferman, or Bang On A Can featured as part of the Ecstatic Music Festival, and Joan Jeanrenaud making beats with PC Muñoz!

It seems that the older generation should be proud of, not to mention reap the benefits of, the years they spent building musical roadways, while the younger generation, which is (and should be) taking advantage of those routes and repaving them using their own materials—as the generation after them will surely do—can always be learning from the past. At this point in my life I feel really lucky to be perched between these two amazing groups! And I can’t wait to find out who will be arriving next, and how they will continue to reshape the musical landscapes of our time.

NewMusicBox provides a space for those engaged with new music to communicate their experiences and ideas in their own words. Articles and commentary posted here reflect the viewpoints of their individual authors; their appearance on NewMusicBox does not imply endorsement by New Music USA.

4 thoughts on “Generation Gap Carousel

  1. composter

    well then
    Nice viewpoint, Alexandra; your perspective is generous. Maybe it’s not surprising that this has not generated previous comment, because the younger generation you speak of does not seem to care about anything other than their own career advocacy; they certainly aren’t interested in Mikel Rouse. Mikel was too busy making genre-busting cultural commentary, instead of designing his self-promotion and website to land himself a place in the industry-approved pantheon. What a loser by today’s standards! Imagine, pushing music into new places instead of pushing his career!

  2. Alexandra Gardner

    @composter – with all due respect, I would like to point out that there are career-oriented, opportunistic composers of every generation; I honestly don’t think that proportionally speaking, there are more in the younger generation than in any other generation. If it seems like there are, it is because there are just so many more composers in the world now – a numbers game.

    I think it is natural for any generation of artists to gravitate more towards their peers—especially when they are young—as a means of discovering what they are doing and how it fits within contemporary culture. I imagine that Mikel Rouse was doing just that when he was 28 years old! Branching out comes with an increased sense of artistic identity.

    There are plenty of younger composers who are incredibly open, kind, generous and interested in those of all ages around them without regard for how their careers will be affected by such behavior. Though in general I do think that members of both generations of composers could make more effort to venture beyond their own habits and preferences.

  3. colin holter

    There are plenty of younger composers who are incredibly open, kind, generous and interested in those of all ages around them without regard for how their careers will be affected by such behavior.

    Alex is 100% right about this; I aspire to the levels of openness, kindness, and generosity that my colleagues show on a regular basis. Nobody’s in this line of work because he or she likes to stick it to the competition.

  4. philmusic

    There are plenty of younger composers who are incredibly open, kind, generous and interested in those of all ages around them without regard for how their careers will be affected by such behavior.

    Yes there are and these are the composers who take real risks.

    Phil Fried

    Phil’s not to young page


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Conversation and respectful debate is vital to the NewMusicBox community. However, please remember to keep comments constructive and on-topic. Avoid personal attacks and defamatory language. We reserve the right to remove any comment that the community reports as abusive or that the staff determines is inappropriate.