One of the many legends surrounding Tsangyang Gyatso (1683-1706), the sixth Dalai Lama of Tibet, was that he upset the order of the universe by physically being in more than one place at a time—a feat beyond mere mortal humans, at least back in the 18th century. Now, thanks to audio and video recording technologies, we can almost “be” in more than one place at a time. Of course, if you are your music, as so many composers claim, we’ve had them all beat by millennia since our music can theoretically be played without us all over the place at the same time. The same is true for visual artists, playwrights, poets, and novelists, too, I suppose, but music seems to draw us closer into someone’s inner soul. (I’m biased, I know.)

However, in our premiere-driven new music society, it is rare to have such a simultaneity. Even the remarkable road tour of Joan Tower’s Made in America is predominantly a staggered sequence of 65 performances. Imagine how cool it would have been if all 65 orchestras around the country were playing the piece at the same time!

While it’s not quite as monumental as that, something similar is happening this week for Elliott Carter. On Thursday night, the Boston Symphony Orchestra will give the world premiere performance of Carter’s Three Occasions. That same night, the Chicago Symphony Orchestra will give the world premiere of Carter’s Soundings. It’s very possible that both pieces will be played at exactly the same time. Chicago and Boston are in two different time zones an hour apart, but Chicago’s program opens with the Carter and Boston plays their Carter at the beginning of the second half of the program.

Now, if you were Carter, what would you do? Which performance would you go to? Luckily, both orchestras are playing these works more than once. As I write this, Carter is at Penn Station headed for Boston to attend the premiere there. (Don’t ask me how I know these things!) The next morning, he boards a plane to attend the second and third performances in Chicago.

Our music has the power to be several places at once, but it’s only events like this that drive the point home. In an era when everyone is prognosticating the end of notated music and argues persuasively for the hegemony of notated and non-notated approaches, events like this celebrate what makes notated music so unique. Carter can’t be in Boston and Chicago at once, but his music can. And while perhaps this may not win over any more journalists who deal in headline news or pro-sports, they’ve got to admit that not even Bernie Williams can simultaneously hit a home run in Fenway and Wrigley Field.

NewMusicBox provides a space for those engaged with new music to communicate their experiences and ideas in their own words. Articles and commentary posted here reflect the viewpoints of their individual authors; their appearance on NewMusicBox does not imply endorsement by New Music USA.

4 thoughts on “Transubstantiation

  1. Tom Myron

    Letter to the Editor Part 2
    Carter’s Three Occaisions have been performed many times (as well as recorded by Oliver Knussen & an expanded London Sinfonietta) since they were written in 1986-89.

  2. Frank J. Oteri

    Tom is indeed correct that Three Occasions has been done many times, but Three Illusions, which is the correct name of the new Carter orchestral piece, will receive its world premiere in Boston on Thursday night.

    First I was confusing Source and Soundings (see above), now this. Well, at least my brain is malfunctioning both uptown and downtown. Either I really need a vacation (but didn’t I just have one), or we really keep mining similar titles.


  3. Garth Trinkl

    Frank, Randy, Molly —

    Nice touch featuring today both Johnny Reinhard’s superb article on Charles Ives entitled “Across the Universe” (which I have skimmed), and George Crumb’s “A Haunted Landscape” .

    I now have my reading material for this evening (after an early NSO concert).

    And I highly look forward to Mr Reinhard’s follow-up article on Ive’s tuning ideas later this autumn.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Conversation and respectful debate is vital to the NewMusicBox community. However, please remember to keep comments constructive and on-topic. Avoid personal attacks and defamatory language. We reserve the right to remove any comment that the community reports as abusive or that the staff determines is inappropriate.