Arnold Rosner
In Memoriam: Arnold Rosner (1945-2013)

In Memoriam: Arnold Rosner (1945-2013)

Arnold Rosner

Arnold Rosner
Photo by Bernadette Bucher.

American composer Arnold Rosner died in his Brooklyn apartment on his 68th birthday, November 8, 2013. Rosner was born in New York City, where his father owned a candy store. He attended the Bronx High School of Science, New York University, and the University of Buffalo, where he earned the first doctorate in music granted by the State University of New York. At the time of his death, Rosner had been on the faculty of Kingsborough Community College (CUNY) for several decades.

Rosner was one of the true maverick composers of his generation. In some ways it is easier to define his approach to music by what he shunned than by what he embraced. Rosner rejected all the compositional styles that seized the limelight during the course of his career. Though in many ways a staunch traditionalist, he didn’t align himself with more conservative approaches either. While he decried what he saw as the sterility of the serialists and the experimentalists, as well as the mindlessness of the minimalists, he also loathed the sentimentality of the neo-romantics and the dry formalism of the neo-classicists. He developed his vision of a musical ideal around the time he entered high school, and, though he refined and elaborated this vision throughout his life, he never repudiated it, and paid a significant price for his stubborn adherence to it.

Rosner’s music was predicated on the modal polyphony of the Renaissance and early Baroque, as well as on the pre-tonal harmony of late Medieval dance music, and the free triadicism and rhythmic phraseology of that music underlay his entire output, regardless of how far from those sources he ventured. He saw a world of difference between the free triadicism of, say, Monteverdi or Gesualdo, and the major-minor dualism of Classical 18th-century tonality, which he despised and found insipid.  He seasoned these rather austere elements with a pinch of Judaica, and combined them with the rich luxuriance of 19th-century orchestration and a Romantic sense of drama. In some works he displayed a Hindemithian vigor and in others the stark brutality of Shostakovich. These basic elements may seem antithetical to each other in many ways, but therein lies the remarkable individuality of Rosner’s music. When he discovered pieces such as the Fantasia on a Theme of Thomas Tallis by Vaughan Williams, Mysterious Mountain by Alan Hovhaness, the symphonies of Carl Nielsen, and the Eleventh Symphony of Shostakovich, he regarded them as precedents that justified the ideal vision he sought to realize. But what makes Rosner’s music worthy of serious consideration, rather than being merely a homogenization of earlier styles, is the way that his unusual language is capable of embracing an enormous expressive range—far broader than one might imagine possible—from serene beauty to violent rage, with many points in between. And despite its fusion of seemingly incongruous elements, most of his music is readily accessible to even untutored listeners.

Fiercely independent, Rosner shunned any of the institutions or organizations with which he might have aligned himself. Although he earned his living in an academic setting, he never took advantage of the opportunities open to academic composers. As desperately as he sought acceptance, he would have it only on his own terms. Without his cultivating opportunities for performance, his music initially attracted the attention of only a small number of equally independent-minded musicians and music lovers. As the years passed, his works gained no foothold within the world of professional musicians, and he became increasingly embittered. Deciding simply to bypass the conventional music institutions, he began to produce recordings of his music and make them available to the public. These recordings, where a sizable portion of his output may be heard, were highly praised by most of the review media, and Rosner began to develop a modest following of committed enthusiasts who recognized the value of his unique voice.

Rosner’s final output comprises more than a hundred compositions: three operas, eight symphonies, six string quartets, three a cappella Mass settings and a large Requiem Mass, three piano sonatas, and a host of other orchestral, choral, and chamber works. Two of his symphonies have been released by Naxos, and six CDs of his music can be found on the Albany label. At the time of his death he was in the middle of a project with the University of Houston Wind Ensemble to record all his music for wind band. Performance materials for Rosner’s music are available from Carson Cooman.

NewMusicBox provides a space for those engaged with new music to communicate their experiences and ideas in their own words. Articles and commentary posted here reflect the viewpoints of their individual authors; their appearance on NewMusicBox does not imply endorsement by New Music USA.

11 thoughts on “In Memoriam: Arnold Rosner (1945-2013)

  1. Harold J. Winston

    It is disappointing that the NY Times ignored Arnold Rosner while he was alive.
    I heard him conduct his 5th Symphony in Colorado in 1975 in a stirring performance. I was also privileged to
    hear his string quarters and other chamber music performed in the Chicago metropolitan area.

  2. Jeffrey Davis

    Such a sad loss of a very fine composer. At least he lived to hear his wonderful 5th Symphony recorded on Naxos.

  3. Shannon Gold

    I was fortunate enough to have Arnold Rosner as my Opera professor at Kingsborough Community College. He made me see Opera in a way I hadn’t before. It’s such a loss to see such a fine man pass away. H

  4. Cecilia

    Professor Rosner was my Music teacher at Kingsborough Community College. He was a very unique individual who left an indelible imprint on my musical knowledge and appreciation. I still think of him and reach for the copies he religiously and generously offered to his students, seven years after taking his classes. Thanks for the memories and sharing your musical passion. Godspeed Fair Genlteman! May you be granted acceptance into that great musical ensemble in the sky. I will continue to hear you throughout my days on earth. “The lives of great men all remind us, we must make our lives sublime and in departing leave behind us footprints on the sands of time.” Peace eternal. Sweet music, Professor Rosner. Until we meet again.

  5. David Law

    I studied orchestration with Prof. Rosner while he was at Brooklyn College. We shared a great appreciation for Dvorak’s 8th symphony. He loved Dvorak’s writing for the brass and pointed out the trombone flurry in the last movement. He was always available to talk. An extremely intelligent and opinionated man. We had several chess matches and he utterly destroyed me. Little did i know then what a brilliant composer he was as well. What a privilege it was to be able to know him and learn from him. A great loss.

  6. Victor Grauer

    I was a fellow student and good friend of Arnie Rosner when we were both grad students at SUNY Buffalo, back in the late ’60s. I very much enjoyed talking music with Arnie and also playing his favorite game of “musical knowledge,” at which he excelled. He had terrible problems as a student because he refused to go along with the trend toward serialism and experimentalism that was so prevalent in Buffalo and on so many other campuses of that time.

    I admit that I too did not fully appreciate Arnie’s music at that time, though I certainly recognized his musical gifts. Recently however, I had the opportunity to hear a remarkable orchestral work on the radio that puzzled me because it sounded like a combination of Vaughn Williams and Hovhaness, but I couldn’t recall ever hearing it before. When the announcement came that it was by Arnold Rosner, that stopped me in my tracks. Because this piece, with a tile of “Alleluia” something, is extraordinarily beautiful, and worthy of either of these two great composers. But it made sense because I recall that Vaughn Williams and Hovhaness were Arnie’s favorite composers when I knew him.
    I did a search today on the Internet to find his email address so I could tell him how much I enjoyed his music. Instead, I found this obituary. What a disappointment and what a shame.

  7. Marc Friedman

    I am a clarinet player and physician who knew Arnie. I cried when, today, I learned that Arnie had passed away. I loved Arnie and had great admiration for him; for his exceptional intelligence, talent, wonderful sense of humor and for the strength of his character. Arnie was a remarkable person and will be missed.


  8. Roland Buck

    “But it made sense because I recall that Vaughn Williams and Hovhaness were Arnie’s favorite composers when I knew him.”
    Rosner wrote his doctoral dissertation on the music of Alan Hovhaness. It is entitled “An Analytical Survey of the Music of Alan Hovhaness.” It was completed in 1972.

  9. Irwin Moss

    A random “blind”selection of cds from my collection included the Laurel Records (LR 849 CD) “Music of Arnold Rosner,” which quite frankly I had forgotten I owned! I went to Google for a refresher on him and found no reference to my CD or the pieces on it. Most are performed by The Jerusalem SO, David Amos, cond. I owe (and owed in the days of LPs) much to Fanfare Mag. and Records International of Goleta, CA from whom I purchased much “obscure” contemporary and historical music. Further to coincidence is the facts that in that random selection is a Gerald Scwarz/Seattle SO of Hovhaness, both “Helena” and “City of Light.” Moreover I have just posted on Amazon my disdain for RVW’s Concerto for Tuba/Orch heard locally on KUSC. I add that I am a long time fan of RVW, (The London and Job are among my favorite orch pieces.) Are there indeed coincidences or are there in fact somethings that are “in the air,” so to speak. The Rosner indeed belongs alongside those composers mentioned in the various notes about him. The music world is missing a fine composer and his work.

  10. Laurence Simon

    I taught psychology at KCC and became good friends with Ar nie over a period of years. I understood his frustration at not being recognized for the quality of his compositions but he was a good teacher and well respected by his students. I retired in 2005 and lost touch with him and am so sorry to learn of his passing. He must have been ecstatic when his fifth symphony appeared with Flagello’s Mass. I have all of his recorded music in my collection and know his work will live on in the future.

  11. Sig Rosen

    Honored to have met Arnold. His ‘approval’ of our edition by Harold Brown (1909-79) of Josquin’s Missa Una musque de Buscaya 4vv- given to him at his 60th Birthday Event at Merkin meant much to me. He said “it had my name on it” Any work by AR is eagerly to be valued. His last Albany TROY 1353 was released next to our Harold Brown String Music- Albany TROY1352. They both had great love of the Renaissance. AR’s L’Homme arme’ masses are amazing.

Comments are closed.